Interviews
Walter
Stark - July 2003
Thanks
for your time Walter. Firstly your background, where were you born and where
were you brought up?
You're welcome. I was born in Scotland and brought up in Blantyre, Strathclyde.
David Livingstone the African explorer came from the same place and I think
the capital of Malawi has the same name.
When did you first become aware
that there was such a thing as Karate?
We had a Judo club at school and somebody said Karate was better so I went
to the library to find out what it was and found "Dynamic Karate".
That was 1971 when I was 13 and I couldn't believe what was in the book.
It was a revelation?
Yes, I was very surprised that the human body could do those things.
How did you get started in Karate
and who was your first Instructor?
A bit later I was taken to a club which just happened to be JKA. The instructor,
Steve Thorburn had just won the Scottish Kumite championship.
What are your earliest memories
of training?
The classes were big, lots of people. Two brothers called Alan and Ricky Jenkins
took us through the basics for a few months before passing us over to the
main beginner's class. We were kept in the basic stances for a long time,
I can remember my legs wobbling uncontrollably when we were finished.
Has anything in particular stuck
in your mind from those early sessions?
How well the instructors moved. They looked so dynamic and the fighting looked
fantastic, just what I wanted.
You wanted to fight?
Yes, I was brought up in a very physical environment where fighting was a
regular thing.
At school?
Everywhere. School, in the street, I'm not saying I liked it but I wasn't
afraid of it.
What was training like in Scotland?
Lots of Kumite. 10 minutes at a time then change, change again, change again.
We really got a feel for fighting early on, you know distancing and follow-through.
The Kihon combinations were complicated compared to what I have seen students
of the same grade doing since. On the whole I think it lacked real detail
into the basic Waza, other than that it was great, good memories.
Did you train with any Japanese
instructors before coming to Australia?
Yes. Enoeda Sensei was the Chief Instructor in the UK. He always invited guest
instructors from Japan to his national seminars, so we got to train with some
big names. Kawazoe Sensei was the Instructor in Scotland.
Scotland has been referred to
as "Northern England"
Has it? Well it lies to the north of that country but it is further away than
Australia to most Scots.
When did you come to live in
Australia?
1981
Are you still in contact with
any of the people you trained with?
No, I think they’ve all quit. I have a mate who now lives in Sydney
who started at the same time but he didn't continue.
Going back, what would you change
if you could start again?
More Kata. The Kumite training has stood me in good stead, we learned how
to give and take a knock or two in the early days, the teachers were good
fighters.
From a Karate point of view,
tell us what it was like coming here and continuing your training with JKA
of Australia.
It was no problem because I wanted to learn more. They did JKA here so I joined
without hesitation.
When did you first meet Takahashi
Sensei and what were your first impressions?
I first met him on one of his visits to Melbourne. He was clearly a JKA Instructor
and he trained, taught and carried himself exactly that way.
When did you first meet Nishimura
Sensei?
In was in early 1982. I had been trying hard to contact Takahashi Sensei who
I was told hadn't been to Melbourne for some months. I couldn't get anyone
to tell me why Sensei hadn't been in town, so I just trained with the students
anyway. Then an old student of his called me to say that a new JKA Instructor
was living in Melbourne. I didn't believe him, but it was true. I have trained
with Nishimura Sensei since the day I met him.
Since coming to Australia, have
you noticed anything that is different about our approach to Karate compared
to elsewhere?
Yes. The difference is that Takahashi Sensei has made sure everyone is grounded
in basic training before anything else can even be contemplated. It was hard
at first, I actually thought I was going backwards, but for me it's been the
right way.
As a new Australian have you
had to adjust much to fit into JKAA?
Yes, but I wanted to fit. JKA is a hierarchical system, which means there
is always someone above and below you, we call this the Sempai/Kohai relationship.
When it comes to the organisational aspect of Karate we need to participate
with the group, individual thinking is fine for your personal Karate but a
group is a group and everybody must try hard to work within that framework.
Do you agree with everything
in the association?
No I don't, but then I don't agree with everything in my marriage or with
what happens at work. On the whole, JKAA is a great organisation, you can
trust the people and it represents something very important to me. It also
has history and continuity, rare and valuable things.
Do you get involved and are you interested
in the Politics of Karate?
The time I have for Karate I spend training.
I participate in discussions as far as our group is concerned when I need
to and I support JKAA in every way I can, that is to say protecting what we
have built and maintaining the integrity of the association. Other than that
I'm too busy training.
What do you think of the standard
of JKA Karate in Australia?
It is high. Generally the basics are as good as any in the world, our seniors
have made that possible.
Describe your training routine.
I just train as much as I can. I lead the Melbourne Instructors' class, that
way I can participate and offer help to the others at the same time.
Do you have a favourite Kata
Bassai Dai and I like Sochin
very much. I'm actually really enjoying Kata at the moment, just many repetitions
and getting a better feeling for the breathing aspect.
What about weights or Gym work?
I do private training including weights, but a lot of Kata. Karate is all
you need if you do everything often enough.
Have you ever trained in another
group?
Occasionally I visit a Kyokushin Dojo just to feel like a novice again, but
my focus is JKA.
What is Kyokushin Karate like?
The moves are quite easy to pick up if you have done JKA and their Dojo Kumite
is similar, but Shiai practice is continuous rather than Ippon based and I
can assure you it is hard work.
What is important to you in
terms of Karate?
In general terms I think continuity and persistence are important. Also, we
must always consider Sensei and the group as a whole.
JKA Melbourne has a good record
of competition credits, why is this?
Because of Nishimura Sensei. He is able to touch a chord in our thinking with
the minimum of effort. A small suggestion here or a word about this or that
rather than push, push, push. That way we pick up the baton and get the job
done ourselves, with the right motivation.
You've coached the JKA Australia
national team for some time. What is your main impression so far?
It's been great. We've stuck to the right path and any results are based purely
on training. We have made excellent progress, especially recently. The commitment
of every single member of our team in the training and competition at Taupo
in March was unbelievable. As far as success at the highest level well, only
one team can win in JKA competitions, and it's an open system in the individual
events as opposed to a weights system, so there are far less champions. But
our people have definitely shown the right signs and I'm convinced our time
is coming. We have a great sporting tradition to live up to in this country
and we will.
Who sticks out as a great performer
from your time as coach so far?
Quite a few. I think Brad Hoffman was the best all-round natural talent but
he didn't reach his full potential. Mike Ettingshausen is a very well-rounded
Karateka and we also have some exceptional girls in the team.
Like all groups, people have
left JKAA for various reasons, perhaps because of some expectation not being
met. Why do you think this is?
I don't know why. I can tell you that JKA in Australia has fundamentally not
changed since the day it was founded. People join full of enthusiasm, or come
from another group, or from overseas, but then move on saying they disagree
with the set up. But if the set up hasn't changed, they must have. Other than
that I don't know, nobody has ever explained anything to me. As for Victoria,
we train first and if friendships come, that's great, but Karate is a serious
business, not a social club.
What would you say are the strengths
and weaknesses of the association?
We are a group of tradesmen just doing the job, not salesmen saying things
or politicians arguing about something or business people trying to maximise
an income. Maybe that's also the weakness but on balance this is the best
way.
Tell us about the early training
at Melbourne Dojo?
Sensei (Nishimura) was at his peak and we worked hard. Sempai Omer Cukovic
was the backbone of the Dojo and we had a good thing going. Against that background,
we had great success in Shiai and most importantly, we developed a terrific
spirit, which I can say is still in our minds.
Has much changed?
The same feeling prevails.
Is your routine different
from say 5 years ago?
No.
…10 or 15 Years ago?
Just refinements, aggregating what I've learned. The force and effect of my
movements seem to be greater now.
Who have been your models if
any, in life and/or Karate?
My teachers and my beautiful wife. Some business people and others have influenced
me as well, but these are the main ones.
Does your wife do Karate?
(Laughs) No, she says it's too boring and she is exactly right.
So you think it's boring?
No
Eh, I'm confused?
If you are married you can understand this and anything else for that matter.
Are you always enthusiastic
about training?
On the way to the Dojo at times I'm not, I sometimes force myself to give
what I should, but that is over very quickly and I can honestly say I have
never left the Dojo feeling anything else but satisfaction. Sore and tired,
yes, but always content and resolved to continue.
Are you conscious of nutrition?
Yes, but it's a complicated subject and I'm not an expert. I think a person's
eating habits need to be closely related to his or her body type. I sometimes
read things about nutrition that just don't make sense.
What kind of mental training
do you do if any?
If you work the body first and over time get to the stage where muscle memory
carries you through, then there is time to think more. For me, Karate thinking
is just training without the sweat. I try to turn the thoughts into actions
or at least reinforce some idea I may have, or something Sensei has said.
How can the average player improve
his mental approach to training?
Make sure the training is honest and long, then reflect. Good surroundings
are necessary, ie the right people and advice based on experience from seniors
who are not selfish.
What would you say are your
strong points and not so strong points?
I didn't understand proper basics until I was Nidan, but I was fighting right
from the beginning. I still feel the positive and negative effects of this.
That's why it is vital that novices are grounded in the basics and not over-exposed
to relatively advanced stuff too early.
How do you relax?
I wrestle with my son or sing and play guitar with my girls or I just lie
down and close my eyes.
If you could radically alter
any of the training you have done so far, what would it be?
Not much at all, I'd do more kihon waza (basics).
How important do you think etiquette
and the Dojo Kun are to Karate?
We are doing something that can mean the difference between living and dying.
If Dojo behaviour is left to how people feel, it is reflected in the Karate.
If your behaviour is modified and supported by the code of training, you have
a better chance of surviving. Can you imagine an Army where anything goes?
Where one unit or individual behaved differently to another? Everyone would
be negatively affected, anarchy! The senior-junior aspect is at the very core
of this. Short answer, extremely important.
When did you stop competing?
I was 40 at the time. I'd had a good run and I felt great but frankly, I was
not getting excited at the prospect any more and I wanted to go deeper into
the Waza, so that was it.
Has your outlook to training
changed now that you have retired from competition Karate?
Yes, I can see what the old masters wrote and said about Kata being so important.
The more I train, the more I can feel a new and deeper relationship with the
JKA Kata.
How did you prepare for the
competitive aspect of Karate and is it different to the preparation you undertake
for, say a grading exam?
I just kept thinking about Karate. In the Dojo we did repeated Shobu-Ippon
or variations using different scenarios, for example you are losing with 10
seconds remaining or it's a draw and your best arm is broken etc. For Kata,
we just called random Shitei Kata in a continuous circle to create Shiai conditions.
Grading exams are more serious of course, that is a case of complete attention
to every detail.
What is the most memorable Kumite
match you took part in and why?
Two come to mind. In about 1979 in the team Kumite event at the Karate Union
of Scotland nationals, I faced Gene Dunnett a Scot and a member of the Great
Britain World Championship winning team. We faced off and although the tension
was very high, neither of us made a single move in the whole match. I was
chuffed that Gene saw fit to do this but I'm sure he would have been able
to make a decisive move if he really wanted to. The other was in about 1985,
I met Sempai Omer Cukovic in a regional event final. We had a great match
of nerves and some nice points were scored then he exploded with a lunge punch
in the third extension to win. Good on him.
Cukovic was good?
A good competition player and also a person with great mental strength. In
his last competition, a second after scoring cleanly on his opponent and well
after the referee had called Yame, he took a full contact punch to the face
with bare knuckles. I was standing one court away and I heard the thud. Sempai
Omer camly stepped back to his line, he had a strange look on his face but
he stood upright in the Yoi position looking at his opponent who was disqualified
from the tournament. It turned out that his jaw and cheekbone were both broken
and the orbit of his eye-socket, but he never fussed or complained. He just
bowed and quietly thanked the doctor who was holding his head, then slipped
away to hospital without even touching his face.
What appeals to you most, Judging
or Coaching and why?
Both are great. They require great refinement and a good eye. Also, your responsibilities
towards other people naturally increase in these roles. I try to listen to
everyone.
Some Karate groups are not as
formal as JKA in relation to Dojo "dressage" ie Seiza, Mokuso, Dojo
Kun etc etc. Do you think JKA places too much emphasis on this?
It's a Japanese art so that's what we do. If it were a Scottish art we'd wear
the Kilt, eh? I believe if you are doing JKA Karate you should do it all.
What is your approach to teaching
Children?
I actually don't do much teaching, but I know it's harder than teaching adults
and their attention wanders so you need to keep it interesting.
Is it ever too late to start
Karate?
There must be a point where it is not practical to take it on. Too sick, too
old, I don't know.
Is it for everyone?
Why not? We've had some very ungainly people in JKA Melbourne who turned out
all right.
You have visited and trained
in Japan many times, what did you think of training there and would you return
for more?
It's fantastic training there but all my trips have been in Summer which is
a killer.
Have you trained at the JKA
Honbu Dojo?
Yes, and at some Universities. Both are different.
Different? it's all JKA isn't it?
University Karate can be unbelievably tough.
It is raw and hard, there is not much teaching, just following. At the Kyokai
(JKA Headquarters) all the teachers have come through the University system
and then through the JKA Instructor Program, so there is an emphasis on teaching,
but it is still hard training.
When were you last at the Headquarters?
In December 2000. I was there up to the last
day at the old Ebisu Dojo. The final day was a grading day and all the main
JKA instructors as well as Sugiura Sensei the Chief Instructor were present,
it was memorable.
Did you notice any difference
in your Karate after the Japan trips?
Yes, a clear improvement in endurance and more determined to keep going.
Do you ever visit other JKA
Dojos in Australia for training?
Not much. We are busy enough at the Melbourne Honbu Dojo but by and large
they all do the same thing anyway.
Do you use or teach any innovative
training methods, ie music, special equipment etc?
I've thought about it but never really done it. Anyway, there isn't enough
time for normal practice.
How do you see the future of
Karate in terms of Competition and Dojo training, much change?
I can't imagine any dramatic shifts coming along. We have very stable rules
and a system that has been refined over many years. I believe we are at a
stage where the spirit of achievement in this country will now kick-in and
our people will start to really excel. It is up to us.
JKA has been said to be “obsessed”
by correct technique, any comment?
I've seen that question before. I fully agree. Experts in any field can be
said to be obsessed with what they do. I'm not sure that it's the right word
but I think if we are obsessed for the right reasons, it can only be good.
No martial art can be perfect,
what would you say, are the strong and weak points of JKA?
I think our range for attacking and defending is far greater than most. We
take a straight line to the target and the high impact of the Waza are all
positives. Our close-in techniques are good at elbow distance but that's not
our favourite place, and then there's the ground. The grappling arts have
re-emerged because they work very well on the deck, they are a perfect complement
to what we do.
The various political splits
and break-ups in Karate including JKA are often spoken of as ‘inevitable’,
do you take any notice of these and do you think any good can come of such
splits?
It hasn't affected us in Australia. Takahashi Sensei and the executive of
JKAA has a very high approval rating, so weaknesses such as we have seen in
other countries thankfully haven’t bothered us.
Martial Arts magazines and the
Internet are great sources of information they have also become open forums
for frank and heavily opinionated material. Inevitably, Karate is often closely
scrutinised. What do you think about this kind of scrutiny?
That's just chit-chat, I've fallen for it myself, but the only real measure
for what we do is what happens in the Dojo.
The general public seems to
be far more familiar than ever before with the fighting arts of the world,
how would you like to have JKA Karate perceived by the average person?
In JKA we don't try too hard to influence people, best to let our Karate do
the talking and if what we do is appealing, then anyone is welcome.
Why have you never taught Karate
for a living?
I did for a short time. There is a fundamental difference in the relationship
with your students if you rely on Karate for a living. A customer is a customer
and you need to provide customer satisfaction if you depend on that for an
income. A student on the other hand is not there to be kept, he is there to
learn. Of course he will stay if the conditions are right but if he leaves,
part of the Instructors livelihood doesn't walk away with him.
So you disagree with teaching
for a living?
Not at all, it can be done very successfully, but for the time being it's
not for me.
The old debate about what is
the “best” fighting art now rages more than ever. If you had time
to prepare for a life-threatening physical challenge (no weapons involved)
what would you do?
This is hypothetical. Having time to prepare is drastically different to the
alternative. OK, I'd be thinking about Ikken Hissatsu and relaxing. I fully
believe what we do in the JKA Dojo is good preparation.
I know that you are very busy
with JKA, but what other Martial Arts have appealed to you?
Yoshinkan Aikido. There's a fella called Joe Thambu in Melbourne who is very
impressive but nothing has grabbed my attention like JKA.
What are your thoughts on particular
breathing methods in Karate? For example, are you conscious of any specific
breathing during a Kata performance?
Yes. This has been on Nishimura Sensei's mind for some time. It's a whole
area of study of it's own but because breathing is the first and the last
thing we ever do, with no breaks in-between, it comes very naturally. The
trick is to maximise our Karate with the breath as another tool, not to ignore
or suppress it.
Have you found or applied any
spiritual aspects to your training?
That's hard to explain. Sometimes I feel a certain easiness in training, even
when the going is fast and furious. Just calmness and the feeling that I could
carry on for ages. Nothing spiritual in the sense of an outside power or anything
though.
When did you first notice this?
I remember in about 1986 we had a Summer Gasshuku at Anglesea surf beach to
the south west of Melbourne. Towards the end of the 3 days we were doing a
full one hour of the same Kata on the sand without a break. It was so tiring
that I just forgot about everything and got on with it. It happened then,
it was fantastic. I'm sure it's another state of consciousness and a natural
thing, the trouble is that it can be elusive.
What do you consider to be the
most important thing about actual Karate training?
The Budo spirit first, but in training high repetition Kihon and Kata are
the most important.
What can you see in the future
for JKA in Australia?
Well, our country is an absolute haven for people to live a safe and prosperous
lifestyle, just look at the number of immigrants that come here. Also, Aussies
are very positive. This coupled with a disciplined art like JKA Karate that
has been around so long and that offers so much to such a broad section of
people, means that the future potentially will be very good for us.
Under what circumstances would
you leave JKA?
I'll just keep going no matter what happens, JKA Karate is a long-term proposition
as we have seen.
You couldn't see yourself out
of it?
I've been involved for a long time, it's given me a lot and I want to keep
going. If things change and I mean radically change, I'd need to think, but
I would never leave of my own accord or act in a way that would threaten to
undo all of our good work. You must be true to your code.
What do you want to do in the
future, personally in Karate?
Firstly, keep training, everything will come from this. I'm not too ambitious
but I'd like to move forward in the Judging area.
Do you have any regrets?
Thousands, but what can you do? Just train.
Walter, thank you very much
for your time, what is the main thing that training in JKA Karate has given
you?
Positivity and a lot of enduring friendships. By the way, congratulations
and good luck with the new website, I'll do what I can to contribute. Oss.
Back
to Interviews
Home
Reproduced
with the kind permission of Walter Stark.
Copyright © Japan Karate Association of Australia (Victoria) Limited 2003